• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar

San Francisco Sports Today

San Francisco Sports News Continuously Updated

  • Baseball
    • A’s
    • Giants
  • Football
    • 49’ers
    • Raiders
  • Basketball
    • Kings
    • Warriers
  • Sharks
  • Earthquakes
  • Colleges
    • San Jose State
    • Stanford
    • University of California, Berkeley

Blogfather Analyzes Montas Trade Using Mind Meld

August 3, 2022 by Athletics Nation

Cincinnati Reds v New York Yankees
“You know what they say: ‘Low arm slot, happy life.’” | Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

Before you mischaracterize me as being a Pollyanna or “shilling for the team,” what I am about to write is not so much my personal opinion as it is my inference around what David Forst and Co. were thinking come August 1st.

A cool way to analyze trades, I think, is to put aside — for at least a moment — your own “expert opinions” as fans not privy to the conversations or context, and to try to figure out how we got from point A (Frankie Montas is on the trade block) to point B (the A’s conclude the best deal is the Yankees haul of LHP Ken Waldichuk, RHP Jose Medina, LHP J.P. Sears, and infielder Cooper Bowman for Montas (and Lou Trivino).

While we can’t compare this offer to offers from other teams, because like all of you we don’t know exactly what they were, we can compare to the list of Yankees prospects that were on the table for discussion between Forst and Brian Cashman.

Here are some of the thoughts I gather went through the A’s collective minds to land on this deal…

There has been some gnashing of teeth that the A’s didn’t procure, in the deal, one of the Yankees top 2 prospects. After all, for Luis Castillo the Mariners parted with prospects ranked #1 and #2 on lists.

Where’s The “Top Prospect”?

We can assume that one prospect who was never in play was Anthony Volpe, but that perhaps the A’s had a shot at Oswald Peraza, a 22 year old shortstop prospect. Most likely Oakland wasn’t going to pry both Peraza and Waldichuk, and more, but perhaps they could have insisted on the higher ranked Peraza instead of Waldichuk.

Here my inference is that internally, the A’s scouting department actually preferred Waldichuk, not because he’s a pitcher and Peraza an infielder, but perhaps because they don’t strongly believe in Peraza or perhaps because they really like Waldichuk. It’s not hard to see why — while Waldichuk was good at St. Mary’s, he has been pretty spectacular as a pro, with 328 Ks in 215.2 IP while allowing just 149 hits. He has K’d 70 in 47.2 IP at AAA this season, showing no signs of slowing down as he moves up the ladder.

Mind Meld #1: You might have liked the trade better had you heard it was Peraza, Sears, Medina, Bowman. Well, consider at least the possibility that the A’s, with scouts and internal analysts on the ground, liked the haul they got even better.

We wanted Nick Effing LaLoosh?

I see not everyone has warmed up to Luis Medina, and if anyone is wondering why they don’t have to look farther than a BB/9IP rates that frighten puppies. Medina has thrown 361.1 minor league innings, and pitching to Rookie league, A and AA prospects he has walked 244 batters.

The MLB discard pile is littered with pitchers who can throw 100 MPH (as Medina does), who are hard to hit but walk 6.07 batters per 9 IP (as Medina has), who have “ace stuff if they can just throw enough strikes”…Is this the kind of risk you want to bank on as part of a deal for Montas?

The answer lies in Medina’s significant upside, even if his floor is grand canyon low. Medina was considered to have one of the very best — if not the best — arms in the Yankees’ system, a guy who could actually be a top-of-the-rotation SP with the stuff he has. He has been listed as the A’s #7 prospect, while Sears comes in at just the low teens.

I watched a promotional video of him, which is always dangerous because it doesn’t show the frequent spells of wildness and a glimpse of what goes wrong when it all goes sideways. But looking at him during some successful moments, man the stuff really does play. His fastball doesn’t just light up the radar gun, it looks electric, and his big curve is pretty much unhittable.

Also noteworthy, to me, is that while I was seeing only a fraction of his performances, what I saw was a pretty free and easy delivery in which he was able to command his pitches. Even if he can’t currently do that nearly often enough, you can see the potential and dream (while salivating), “What if he were able to repeat that delivery more often…?” You might have yourself an ace.

He’s not there, of course, not even close. But he is making baby steps. His BB/9IP rate at AA this season is 5.00. Which is better than 6, I’m just saying. He’s still only 23 and now gets to work with an organization that has had success developing pitchers.

Mind meld #2: To have made this trade, with Medina as a key piece, I have to think that the A’s believe they can work with Medina’s mechanics and delivery to significantly address the control issues. Not that he will ever be “Cole Irvin level” stingy with the walks, but while Wandisson Charles simply can’t throw strikes — it doesn’t appear to be in his range of potential skill sets no matter what coaches try — A’s scouts and coaches must see in Medina fixable problems they feel they understand and can work with. If so, you might yourself a heck of a pitcher. (And if not, he will be a lot like the lottery tickets you have bought in real life that yielded nothing but disappointment.)

Sears: Under The Radar And Underappreciated

From everything I can see, J.P. Sears is actually quite good. He is noted as having a fastball that “plays up” because of his arm slot and generates more swings and misses than you would expect given average velocity (93 MPH).

Sometimes the hitters tell you how good you are, and in Sears’ case at every level the hitters have said, “Well I can’t really hit you.” Here are his stats:

Short A 2017: 0.69 ERA, 27.2 IP, 13 hits, 12 BB, 51 K

Full A 2017 0.00 ERA, 17 IP, 7 hits, 9 BB, 29 K

Full A 2018: 2.67 ERA, 54 IP, 38 hits, 11 BB, 54 K

Advanced A 2019: 4.07 ERA, 48.2 IP, 41 hits, 16 BB, 45 K

AA 2021 4.09 ERA, 50.2 IP, 45 hits, 18 BB, 71 K

AAA 2021: 2.87 ERA, 53.1 IP, 41 hits, 11 BB, 65 K

AAA 2022: 1.67 ERA, 43 IP, 24 hits, 7 BB, 55 K

Put all together, his minor league totals show 277.1 IP, 202 hits, 75 BB, 341 K

Oh, and in the big leagues? 3-0, 2.05 ERA, 22 IP, 14 hits, 5 BB, 15 K

Mind meld #3: I think the A’s tabbed Sears as a guy who is better than his rankings or his pedigree (he’s an 11th round pick, #333 overall), whose track record from Rookie ball to The Show shows who he actually is.

As for Bowman, I don’t know if he was a key piece in the deal or more of a lottery ticket/filler to round out the deal. Hopefully he reaches the big leagues and contributes, and in a perfect world he goes all Mark Ellis on the league coming out of nowhere (specifically Stevens High School in Rapid City, South Dakota), but it’s unlikely the deal ever hinged on whether he, or a comparable prospect, rounded out the trade.

Conclusion: So perhaps the A’s were offered Peraza or Waldichuk and actually preferred Waldichuk. Maybe they see, in Medina, ace stuff they feel their coaching staff has a real shot to harness. It could be they coveted Sears as if he was a “top 5” prospect, even though he doesn’t appear that way on any boards. You can certainly do worse than a 4th round pick as your “last piece”.

This is all to say why the A’s might have been more bullish on this group of 4 than you will be just to glance at prospect boards and compare to the absurd overpay the Mariners made for a somewhat comparable SP. While we’re busy gnashing teeth, the A’s front office could be high fiving that they “got their guys”.

And in just a few years we’ll know who was right.

Filed Under: A's

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Two-Way Deals: 7/1/25
  • ESPN wants the 49ers to extend this player who is far from a fan favorite
  • Who is the 49ers “safety blanket” receiver?
  • Has Brock Purdy become underrated?
  • 49ers 90-in-90: San Francisco’s second-round pick might be the Niners’ most important rookie in 2025

Categories

  • 49'ers
  • A's
  • Earthquakes
  • Giants
  • Kings
  • Raiders
  • San Jose State
  • Sharks
  • Stanford
  • Uncategorized
  • University of California, Berkeley
  • Warriers

Archives

  • July 2025
  • June 2025
  • May 2025
  • April 2025
  • March 2025
  • February 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • June 2024
  • May 2024
  • April 2024
  • March 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021

Our Partners

All Sports

  • San Francisco Chronicle
  • San Francisco Examiner
  • The Mercury News
  • 247 Sports
  • Bleacher Report
  • Forgotten 5
  • Golden Gate Sports
  • The Sports Fan Journal
  • The Spun
  • USA Today

Baseball

  • San Francisco Giants
  • Oakland A's
  • Last Word On Baseball - Oakland A's
  • Last Word On Baseball - San Francisco Giants
  • MLB Trade Rumors - A's
  • MLB Trade Rumors - Giants
  • White Cleat Beat
  • Around The Foghorn
  • Athletics Nation
  • McCovey Chronicles

Basketball

  • Golden State Warriors
  • Sacramento Kings
  • A Royal Pain
  • Amico Hoops - Kings
  • Amico Hoops - Warriors
  • Blue Man Hoop
  • Golden State Of Mind
  • Hoops Hype - Warriors
  • Hoops Hype - Kings
  • Hoops Rumors - Warriors
  • Hoops Rumors - Kings
  • Lets Go Warriors
  • Last Word On Pro Basketball - Golden State
  • Last Word On Pro Basketball - Sacramento
  • Pro Basketball Talk - Warriors
  • Pro Basketball Talk - Kings
  • Real GM - Warriors
  • Real GM - Kings
  • Sactown Royalty

Football

  • San Francisco 49ers
  • Las Vegas Raiders
  • 49ers Gab
  • Just Blog Baby
  • Last Word On Pro Football
  • NFL Trade Rumors - San Francisco 49ers
  • NFL Trade Rumors - Las Vegas Raiders
  • Niners Nation
  • Niner Noise
  • Niners Wire
  • Our Turf Football
  • Pro Football Rumors - 49ers
  • Pro Football Rumors - Raiders
  • Pro Football Talk - 49ers
  • Pro Football Talk - Raiders
  • Raiders Wire
  • Silver And Black Pride
  • Total 49ers

Hockey

  • Blades Of Teal
  • Fear The Fin
  • Last Word On Hockey
  • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Talk
  • The Hockey Writers

Soccer

  • Center Line Soccer
  • Last Word on Soccer
  • MLS Multiplex

College

  • Busting Brackets
  • California Golden Blogs
  • College Sports Madness
  • College Football News
  • Rule Of Tree
  • Saturday Blitz
  • The Daily Californian
  • The Stanford Daily
  • Zags Blog

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in