• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar

San Francisco Sports Today

San Francisco Sports News Continuously Updated

  • Baseball
    • A’s
    • Giants
  • Football
    • 49’ers
    • Raiders
  • Basketball
    • Kings
    • Warriers
  • Sharks
  • Earthquakes
  • Colleges
    • San Jose State
    • Stanford
    • University of California, Berkeley

Do the Giants have “15 or 16 legitimate starters?”

January 30, 2025 by McCovey Chronicles

Cincinnati Reds v San Francisco Giants
Photo by Andy Kuno/San Francisco Giants/Getty Images

Do you agree? A comment from Giants pitching coach J.P. Martinez inspired some skepticism from some ball-knowers.

This morning, I listened to Mike Ferrin and Jim Duquette discuss on their Power Alley show for SiriusXM the interview Andrew Baggarly posted to The Athletic yesterday (sub required) with new pitching coach J.P. Martinez. They were piqued by Martinez’s comment that went in the headline, that “We will have 15 or 16 legitimate starters,” and that compelled them to start an exercise I think we can finish.

Do the San Francisco Giants really have 15 or 16 legitimate starters right now?

This isn’t an abstraction about which prospects could become starters at some point in the near future. Martinez’s full quote is unambiguous:

[…] it will be the first time in big-league camp since I’ve been here that we will have 15 or 16 legitimate starters — upper-level, legitimate guys that can start. To have that workload and that experience and to see the competition amongst that group will be huge for us. We want to feel like when guys get to the big leagues, they’re prepared to contribute and not treading water or trying to survive.

With that in mind, let’s see if we can get to 15 or 16.

Power Alley is the only baseball show I care to listen to — so, I’m as skeptical as they are regarding the matter, but we follow the team a bit more closely so I think we might be able to answer this a bit better. Ferrin and Duquette were only able to get to maybe 14.

Full disclosure before we begin: I think their show is great. Mike Ferrin is a perfect ambassador for MLB. I interviewed him on the old McCovey Chronicles podcast; if you don’t know who he is, here’s a bio. Duquette is a baseball exec who was briefly the Mets’ GM.

The obvious (6)

  1. Logan Webb
  2. Robbie Ray
  3. Justin Verlander
  4. Kyle Harrison
  5. Jordan Hicks
  6. Hayden Birdsong

Regardless of how you feel about some names in this bunch, I think it’s pretty easy to say — just for the sake of defending Martinez’s comment — that these are no doubt starters.

The could-bes (11)

  1. Landen Roupp
  2. Tristan Beck
  3. Keaton Winn
  4. Mason Black
  5. Trevor McDonald

I have my doubts about Beck as a starter — his return from the aneurysm last season was wonderful to see, but I really think he’s effective in that Jakob Junis role of 2-3 innings at a time with the occasional stretch to 4 innings. Still, that’s, effectively, a starter in today’s game. Winn’s health might prevent him from being anything more than a reliever, and he’s still working his way back from ulnar nerve transposition surgery which could hinder his availability and, therefore usage.

Basically, this group “feels” like it’s tilting 55-45 in favor of them being relievers, but they all have starter upside.

The Carsons (14)

  1. Carson Whisenhunt
  2. Carson Ragsdale
  3. Carson Seymour

Whisenhunt is ranked as the McCovey Chronicles’ #2 overall prospect for the Giants. As Brady wrote in the ranking post:

In 25 starts and 104.2 innings with the River Cats, Whisenhunt had a 5.42 ERA and a 4.66 FIP. Those aren’t standout numbers, but they look a lot better when you remember that Whisenhunt had thrown just 66.1 innings in the Minors prior to this year.

The most impressive part of his performance, though, was the strikeouts. The lefty, who just turned 24 and was the team’s second-round pick in 2022, struck out 11.61 batters per nine innings pitched. That figure was ninth-highest among the 92 Pacific Coast League pitchers with at least 50 innings last year.

Meanwhile, Ragsdale might be a better fit as a power reliever, but the Giants have been developing him as a starting pitcher. He’ll turn 27 in May and so I’d imagine he’d at least get a spot start in 2025.

Seymour’s spot on this list seems a little iffy, to be honest. As Brady wrote a couple of weeks ago, after the McCovey Chronicles community ranked him the #21 prospect:

[…] while he’s been developed as a starter, don’t be surprised if his first — and perhaps only — opportunities come in relief.

The rest (17?)

  1. Joey Lucchesi
  2. Kai-Wei Teng
  3. Enny Romero

Now, the word “legitimate” has always been thrown around — usually in the form of “legit” — and like, say, the word “literally,” it’s true meaning has been diluted by this overuse, and so it’s in that spirit that I mention these three.

We’ve seen Kai-Wei Teng and witnessed his inability to throw strikes. But, the team did re-sign him after he cleared waivers and elected free agency. They obviously see something in there. We’ll find out if he winds up being converted to a reliever. But, technically, he’s a starter with some experience.

Meanwhile, Lucchesi and Romero are probably relievers if they get near the major league roster, but it’s worth pointing out that 77 of Lucchesi’s 81 major league appearances were in a starting role; and, despite appearing mostly as a reliever in 5 MLB seasons (his last one being in 2018), Romero was developed by the Tampa Bay Rays as a starter and since being bounced out of the bigs, he’s been a starter in Japan and Dominican leagues.

Carson Seymour, Joey Lucchesi, Kai-Wei Teng, and Enny Romero don’t scream legitimate starter, so, that drops the count where I feel comfortable taking this list to down to 14. Which — hey — that’s basically where the hosts landed.

Baggarly’s interview doesn’t point us towards any dark horse candidates and I’m not confident that I’ve turned over every stone. Does this list support J.P. Martinez’s assertion? Or do you agree with Ferrin & Duquette? Do you think some names should be swapped out with others? Feel that more names should be added to the list because the team’s pitching depth cup truly runneth over?

Filed Under: Giants

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • 49ers trivia: Your in-5 daily game, Wednesday edition
  • Elephant Rumblings: Draft begins this weekend
  • Wednesday BP: What do you think about the All-Star roster?
  • Keith Law speculates that Giants will not pass on UCSB ace in 2025 MLB Draft
  • No. 4 prospect strikes out eight in strong relief outing at Triple-A

Categories

  • 49'ers
  • A's
  • Earthquakes
  • Giants
  • Kings
  • Raiders
  • San Jose State
  • Sharks
  • Stanford
  • Uncategorized
  • University of California, Berkeley
  • Warriers

Archives

  • July 2025
  • June 2025
  • May 2025
  • April 2025
  • March 2025
  • February 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • June 2024
  • May 2024
  • April 2024
  • March 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021

Our Partners

All Sports

  • San Francisco Chronicle
  • San Francisco Examiner
  • The Mercury News
  • 247 Sports
  • Bleacher Report
  • Forgotten 5
  • Golden Gate Sports
  • The Sports Fan Journal
  • The Spun
  • USA Today

Baseball

  • San Francisco Giants
  • Oakland A's
  • Last Word On Baseball - Oakland A's
  • Last Word On Baseball - San Francisco Giants
  • MLB Trade Rumors - A's
  • MLB Trade Rumors - Giants
  • White Cleat Beat
  • Around The Foghorn
  • Athletics Nation
  • McCovey Chronicles

Basketball

  • Golden State Warriors
  • Sacramento Kings
  • A Royal Pain
  • Amico Hoops - Kings
  • Amico Hoops - Warriors
  • Blue Man Hoop
  • Golden State Of Mind
  • Hoops Hype - Warriors
  • Hoops Hype - Kings
  • Hoops Rumors - Warriors
  • Hoops Rumors - Kings
  • Lets Go Warriors
  • Last Word On Pro Basketball - Golden State
  • Last Word On Pro Basketball - Sacramento
  • Pro Basketball Talk - Warriors
  • Pro Basketball Talk - Kings
  • Real GM - Warriors
  • Real GM - Kings
  • Sactown Royalty

Football

  • San Francisco 49ers
  • Las Vegas Raiders
  • 49ers Gab
  • Just Blog Baby
  • Last Word On Pro Football
  • NFL Trade Rumors - San Francisco 49ers
  • NFL Trade Rumors - Las Vegas Raiders
  • Niners Nation
  • Niner Noise
  • Niners Wire
  • Our Turf Football
  • Pro Football Rumors - 49ers
  • Pro Football Rumors - Raiders
  • Pro Football Talk - 49ers
  • Pro Football Talk - Raiders
  • Raiders Wire
  • Silver And Black Pride
  • Total 49ers

Hockey

  • Blades Of Teal
  • Fear The Fin
  • Last Word On Hockey
  • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Talk
  • The Hockey Writers

Soccer

  • Center Line Soccer
  • Last Word on Soccer
  • MLS Multiplex

College

  • Busting Brackets
  • California Golden Blogs
  • College Sports Madness
  • College Football News
  • Rule Of Tree
  • Saturday Blitz
  • The Daily Californian
  • The Stanford Daily
  • Zags Blog

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in